Pizza Shop Best Of 2020Best of 2022Best of 2024 27 Water Street Newburgh, New York, 12550 Phone: 845-565-7467 Restaurant Category: Italian and Pizzeria Profile The Pizza Shop serves staples like pizza, pasta, and wings, but carefully reimagined for new, exciting twists on old-school classics. Let this business know you found them on Hudson Valley's Online Directories. Features Locations Newburgh 27 Water Street Newburgh, New York 12550 Claim/Edit Listing